# Rootage YAML
metadata:
  id: action-button
  name: Action Button

# Design Guidelines MDX
---
title: Action Button  # Must match
---

# React Docs MDX
---
title: Action Button  # Must match
---

rootage.metadata.name === designDocs.title === reactDocs.title

# Design Guidelines
description: 사용자가 특정 액션을 실행할 수 있도록 도와주는 컴포넌트입니다.

# React Docs - MUST match exactly
description: 사용자가 특정 액션을 실행할 수 있도록 도와주는 컴포넌트입니다.

designDocs.description === reactDocs.description

# Rootage defines
definitions:
  variant=brandSolid: {...}
  variant=neutralSolid: {...}
  size=medium: {...}
  size=large: {...}

# Design guidelines MUST document
| 속성    | 값                              |
| variant | brand solid, neutral solid      |  # Must match YAML
| size    | medium, large                   |  # Must match YAML

extractedPropsFromYAML ⊆ documentedPropsінDesignDocs
// Documented props should cover all YAML-defined props

# Design Guidelines
<PlatformStatusTable componentId="action-button" />  # Must match metadata.id
<ComponentSpecBlock id="action-button" />             # Must match metadata.id

<PlatformStatusTable componentId="X" /> where X === rootage.metadata.id
<ComponentSpecBlock id="X" /> where X === rootage.metadata.id

# Rootage defines
schema:
  slots:
    root: {...}
    label: {...}
    icon: {...}
    prefixIcon: {...}
    suffixIcon: {...}

# Design guidelines should explain:
- Icon usage (prefixIcon, suffixIcon, icon-only layout)
- Label positioning
- Root container behavior

Component ID | Rootage YAML | Design Docs | React Docs | Status
-------------|--------------|-------------|-----------|-------
action-button|      ✓       |      ✓      |     ✓     | Complete
checkbox     |      ✓       |      ✓      |     ✓     | Complete
new-comp     |      ✓       |      ✗      |     ✗     | Missing docs

1. Glob all Rootage YAML files: packages/rootage/components/*.yaml
2. Extract component IDs from metadata.id
3. Build component inventory

// Glob to find all YAML files
const yamlFiles = await glob('packages/rootage/components/*.yaml')

// Read each file and extract metadata.id
for (const file of yamlFiles) {
  const content = await read(file)
  const yaml = parseYAML(content)
  const componentId = yaml.metadata.id
  inventory.push(componentId)
}

For each component ID:
  1. Check existence:
     - docs/content/docs/components/{id}.mdx
     - docs/content/react/components/{id}.mdx
  2. Flag missing files

for (const id of inventory) {
  const designDocsPath = `docs/content/docs/components/${id}.mdx`
  const reactDocsPath = `docs/content/react/components/${id}.mdx`

  const designExists = await fileExists(designDocsPath)
  const reactExists = await fileExists(reactDocsPath)

  if (!designExists) issues.push({ id, type: 'missing_design_docs' })
  if (!reactExists) issues.push({ id, type: 'missing_react_docs' })
}

For each complete set:
  1. Read all three files
  2. Extract metadata:
     - Names (title, metadata.name)
     - Descriptions
     - Props/variants/sizes
     - Component references (componentId, id)
  3. Compare values
  4. Report inconsistencies

// Read files
const yamlContent = await read(yamlPath)
const designContent = await read(designPath)
const reactContent = await read(reactPath)

// Parse frontmatter
const designFrontmatter = parseFrontmatter(designContent)
const reactFrontmatter = parseFrontmatter(reactContent)

// Compare names
if (yaml.metadata.name !== designFrontmatter.title) {
  issues.push({
    id,
    type: 'name_mismatch',
    expected: yaml.metadata.name,
    actual: designFrontmatter.title
  })
}

// Compare descriptions
if (designFrontmatter.description !== reactFrontmatter.description) {
  issues.push({
    id,
    type: 'description_mismatch',
    design: designFrontmatter.description,
    react: reactFrontmatter.description
  })
}

For each component:
  1. Parse Rootage YAML definitions
  2. Extract:
     - Variants: keys matching "variant="
     - Sizes: keys matching "size="
     - States: base.* keys
  3. Read design guidelines Props table
  4. Compare extracted vs documented
  5. Flag missing or extra props

// Extract props from YAML
const definitions = yaml.data.definitions
const variants = Object.keys(definitions)
  .filter(key => key.startsWith('variant='))
  .map(key => key.replace('variant=', ''))

const sizes = Object.keys(definitions)
  .filter(key => key.startsWith('size='))
  .map(key => key.replace('size=', ''))

const states = Object.keys(definitions.base || {})

// Extract props from design docs (using Grep)
const propsTableMatch = await grep({
  pattern: '\\| variant\\s+\\|.*\\|',
  path: designPath,
  output_mode: 'content'
})

// Parse table and compare
const documentedVariants = parsePropsTable(propsTableMatch)

const missingVariants = variants.filter(v => !documentedVariants.includes(v))
if (missingVariants.length > 0) {
  issues.push({
    id,
    type: 'missing_variants',
    missing: missingVariants
  })
}

// Check PlatformStatusTable componentId
const platformStatusMatch = await grep({
  pattern: '<PlatformStatusTable componentId="([^"]+)"',
  path: designPath,
  output_mode: 'content'
})

const extractedId = extractComponentId(platformStatusMatch)
if (extractedId !== yaml.metadata.id) {
  issues.push({
    id,
    type: 'platform_status_id_mismatch',
    expected: yaml.metadata.id,
    actual: extractedId
  })
}

// Check ComponentSpecBlock id
const specBlockMatch = await grep({
  pattern: '<ComponentSpecBlock id="([^"]+)"',
  path: designPath,
  output_mode: 'content'
})

const specId = extractComponentId(specBlockMatch)
if (specId !== yaml.metadata.id) {
  issues.push({
    id,
    type: 'spec_block_id_mismatch',
    expected: yaml.metadata.id,
    actual: specId
  })
}

# Consistency Report

## Summary
- Total components: 28
- Fully consistent: 22
- Issues found: 6

## Issues

### Critical (Must Fix)
1. **badge**: Design docs missing Props table
2. **chip**: Description mismatch between design/react docs

### Warnings (Review)
1. **avatar**: Rootage defines size=xlarge but design docs don't document it
2. **callout**: ComponentSpecBlock id="callouts" (should be "callout")

### Missing Documentation
1. **divider**: Has YAML, missing design guidelines
2. **dialog**: Has YAML, missing React docs

## Recommendations
{Actionable fixes with file paths and specific changes}

"Run docs consistency checker on all components"

"Check docs consistency for action-button"

"Find components with missing documentation"

"Validate that all component props match Rootage specs"

✅ action-button - Fully consistent
⚠️  checkbox - Warning: Description differs slightly
❌ badge - Critical: Missing Props table
📋 divider - Missing: Design guidelines not found

## action-button
Status: ✅ Fully consistent

Checks performed:
- ✅ Name consistency (Action Button)
- ✅ Description matches
- ✅ Props table matches YAML (6/6 props documented)
- ✅ Component IDs correct
- ✅ All files exist

## checkbox
Status: ⚠️  Warning

Checks performed:
- ✅ Name consistency (Checkbox)
- ⚠️  Description differs:
  - Design: "사용자가 하나 이상의 옵션을 선택할 수 있게 해주는..."
  - React:  "사용자가 하나 이상의 옵션을 선택할 수 있게 해주는..."
  - Diff: Extra text in react docs
- ✅ Props table matches YAML
- ✅ Component IDs correct
- ✅ All files exist

Recommendation: Align descriptions in both files

# SEED Design Documentation Consistency Report
Generated: 2025-01-21

## Overall Status
- Total Components: 58
- Fully Consistent: 48 (82.8%)
- With Warnings: 6 (10.3%)
- Critical Issues: 2 (3.4%)
- Missing Docs: 2 (3.4%)

## Critical Issues (Must Fix Immediately)

### 1. badge
**Issue**: Design docs missing Props table
**Impact**: Users cannot understand component options
**Fix**: Add Props table to `/docs/content/docs/components/badge.mdx`

### 2. chip
**Issue**: Description mismatch
**Details**:
- Design: "정보를 표현하고 선택을 나타내는 컴포넌트입니다."
- React: "사용자 입력을 나타내는 컴포넌트입니다."
**Fix**: Align descriptions in both files

## Warnings (Review Soon)

### 1. avatar
**Issue**: Missing variant documentation
**Details**: Rootage defines `size=xlarge` but design docs only show small, medium, large
**Fix**: Add xlarge size to Props table

### 2. callout
**Issue**: ComponentSpecBlock ID typo
**Details**: Uses `id="callouts"` but should be `id="callout"`
**Fix**: Change ComponentSpecBlock id in design docs

## Missing Documentation

### 1. divider
**Missing**: Design guidelines
**Path**: `/docs/content/docs/components/divider.mdx`
**Status**: Rootage YAML exists, React docs exist

### 2. dialog
**Missing**: React documentation
**Path**: `/docs/content/react/components/dialog.mdx`
**Status**: Rootage YAML exists, design docs exist

## Recommendations

1. **Immediate Actions** (Critical):
   - Fix badge Props table
   - Align chip descriptions

2. **This Week** (Warnings):
   - Document avatar xlarge size
   - Fix callout ComponentSpecBlock ID

3. **This Sprint** (Missing Docs):
   - Create divider design guidelines
   - Write dialog React documentation

## Next Steps

1. Assign issues to owners
2. Create tracking tasks
3. Re-run validation after fixes
4. Schedule regular monthly audits

rootage.metadata.name === designDocs.title === reactDocs.title

designDocs.description === reactDocs.description

extractedPropsFromYAML ⊆ documentedPropsInDesignDocs
// Documented props should cover all YAML-defined props

<PlatformStatusTable componentId="X" /> where X === rootage.metadata.id
<ComponentSpecBlock id="X" /> where X === rootage.metadata.id

if (rootageYAML.exists()) {
  designDocs.shouldExist() // Warning if missing
  reactDocs.shouldExist()  // Info if missing (may be WIP)
}

try {
  const content = await read(filePath)
} catch (error) {
  if (error.code === 'ENOENT') {
    issues.push({ type: 'file_not_found', path: filePath })
  } else {
    throw error
  }
}